Oblivion talk:Tidewater Cave

Proposal to move Tidewater Cave Region from Topal Bay to Blackwood Region

Hi,

May I start a discussion about the Cryodil region Tidewater Cave has been allocated to. Could I suggest that it be moved from Topal Bay region to Blackwood region due to the following:

Topal Bay region is not listed as a region in the Oblivion:Regions page. So if you are browsing the Wiki for locations through the Oblivion:Regions page, you will not find Tidewater Cave listed anywhere. You have to access it through either quests or do a search.

In the Topal Bay wiki page Topal Bay is not described as a region. However in the Tidewater Cave wiki page it states in the Info table on the right hand side of the page that the region for Tidewater Cave is in the Topal Bay Region yet there is no such region. In the Topal_Bay wiki page it mentions that Deepscorn Hollow (From the Vile Lair plugin) is located in Topal Bay but if you go to the Deepscorn Hollow wiki page it states that it is located in Blackwood. I therefore think that Tidewater Cave region should also be set to Blackwood and the Blackwood Wiki page should have Tidewater Cave added to the locations section of Blackwood in line with Deepscorn Hollow.

So to summarise I think that Tidewater Cave region should be set to Blackwood becuase Topal Bay is not classed as a region.

Thanks

Smithy*TBE* 08:29, 16 October 2008 (EDT)

I agree: for consistency the "regions" section of the infobox should list one of the established regions in the game; those regions also can be defined unambiguously, based on the regions provided in-game. I've changed this page and made several related changes on other pages. --Nephele^Talk 15:26, 22 October 2008 (EDT)

Seems fair enough. When I added regions to the location pages I just went for whatever the game said, because I wasn't sure exactly how things linked together. Now they're all done and we can see what the actual regions are, it makes sense to consolidate. –Rpeh^{•T•C•E•} 08:33, 23 October 2008 (EDT)