User talk:Vinovin15

The UESPWiki – Your source for The Elder Scrolls since 1995
Jump to: navigation, search

Hello![edit]

Featured Articles[edit]

I had to revert your contribution to Featured Articles. You're absolutely welcome to disagree or constructively point out any flaws you believe UESP has, but please avoid aggressive language and ascribing motives to people that aren't explicitly stated. Phrases like "you people are", "Bethesda doesn't give a shit about" and referring to us as a "cesspool" are good examples of that, among others. Robin Hood(talk) 18:47, 23 April 2023 (UTC)

Further to what Robin Hood has said, please do not conflate the comments made on the FA-worthiness of the article with a personal attack on your efforts to expand the article. No one is saying that it's a bad article or that they do not appreciate the time and effort you have put into improving it; on the contrary, another editor found the article worthy of a Featured Article nomination, which is a compliment. The fact that other editors feel the article is not yet ready for FA status is not a reflection of your efforts, it's a reflection of the fact that Featured Articles are held to an extremely high standard, one which the vast majority of articles on the wiki would not meet for one reason or another. It doesn't mean they're bad articles or that the efforts of their contributors are being criticized, it simply means they don't fit the criteria or that there is room for further improvement. The fact that people do not feel this article meets the criteria should not be taken in any way as a criticism or denigration of your efforts.
If you feel that you have done all you can on the article, then simply say so and take a step back and let other editors contribute what they can. Remember that the wiki is a collaborative effort by volunteer editors who contribute their free time to the improvement of the site, and that there are guidelines in place as to the behaviour expected from all contributors. If you disagree with something another editor has posted, please post your concerns in a civil and respectful manner.
Your contributions to the improvement of the wiki are appreciated, and I hope you will continue to contribute in the future. — Wolfborn(Howl) 19:54, 23 April 2023 (UTC)